A New Durbin Amendment Would Spell Trouble for U.S. Credit Card Customers

Congress Should Learn Its Lesson and Leave Well Enough Alone

  

There are times when we are uncertain what will happen if a particular public policy is implemented. A proposal in Congress about cuts in interchange fees on credit cards is not one of them.

We can be pretty certain that customer services and security for anyone with a credit card will be impacted, and low-income consumers will bear the brunt of this change.

How do we know this? We have been here before and the data is clear.

In 2010, Congress passed the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act, which included a federal price control strategy that capped debit card interchange fees for banks with assets of $10 billion. Interchange fees are charged to merchants by card networks for processing a debit or credit payment.

The Durbin Amendment—named after its primary sponsor, Senator Richard Durbin—altered the structure of the debit card payment processing industry by allowing only incremental costs related to debit card transactions, restricting recovery for many other costs related to card operations, such as customer service, data services, and fraud and loss protection. Unsurprisingly, this effectively transformed debit card operations.

Supporters of the amendment argued that costs to consumers would be lowered by retailers passing on their savings to consumers; however, the Federal Reserve found that most retailers either maintained or raised their prices following the passage of the Durbin Amendment.

So where was the impact of the Durbin amendment felt? Look to the low-income households who were squeezed out of the banking system when decisions on how to offset the billions lost annually due to the regulation were made.

The lost revenue led to reduced access to free banking accounts and increases in fees, as well as a reduction in debit card rewards programs and higher minimum balance requirements. In 2009, the year before Dodd-Frank, 76 percent of checking accounts were free of charge. In 2011, right after Dodd-Frank, just 45 percent were still free. Within three years, the total number of banks offering free accounts fell by 50 percent and the minimum monthly holding required and fees doubled for accounts.

Documents to download

Previous Article 2021 How Florida Compares: Taxes
Next Article Budget Watch - FLORIDA GENERAL REVENUE COLLECTIONS HAVE OUTPACED ESTIMATES FOR 14 CONSECUTIVE MONTHS
Print
44174
0Upvote 0Downvote
«August 2025»
MonTueWedThuFriSatSun
2829
The Census Undercount Limits Florida’s Political Influence

The Census Undercount Limits Florida’s Political Influence

The Census Undercount Hurts Florida’s Political Influence, demonstrates that the 2020 Census missed about 750,000 Floridians — 3.48 % of the population. Correcting that error with U.S. Census Bureau methodology shows the undercount shifted three U.S. House seats nationally: Colorado, Minnesota, and Rhode Island would each lose a seat, while Florida, Tennessee, and Texas would each gain one — raising Florida’s delegation to 29 seats instead of 28.

Read more
3031123
45
Florida TaxWatch 2025 Legislative Session Wrap-Up: Extended Session Edition - Includes Final Budget, Tax Package, and Vetoes

Florida TaxWatch 2025 Legislative Session Wrap-Up: Extended Session Edition - Includes Final Budget, Tax Package, and Vetoes

Florida TaxWatch's 2025 Legislative Session Wrap-up Report provides a comprehensive analysis of Florida's extended legislative session that concluded June 16 with a $115.1 billion budget and $2.0 billion tax package. The Governor signed the budget on June 30 and issued $376 million in line-item vetoes, resulting in a net budget of $114.8 billion while maintaining strong fiscal reserves of $12.6 billion.

Read more
67
Hospice and Palliative Care

Hospice and Palliative Care

Florida's aging population is driving sustained demand for cost-effective, patient-centered care across the continuum. Palliative care—non-curative, interdisciplinary support for patients with serious but often nonterminal conditions—improves quality of life and can lower overall costs when introduced early in the disease course. Hospice provides end-of-life care once a clinician certifies a terminal prognosis; in Florida, hospice providers operate under a Certificate of Need (CON) program that authorizes new entrants only when unmet need is demonstrated through twice-yearly batching cycles.

Read more
8910
1112
Update on the Implementation of the Live Local Act

Update on the Implementation of the Live Local Act

Florida continues to face a severe affordability gap in housing. In 2022, 35% of households were cost-burdened, and by 2024 the state was short more than 323,000 affordable units for households at 0–30% of Area Median Income (AMI). The Legislature’s 2023 Live Local Act—amended in 2024 and 2025—was designed to accelerate supply by combining incentives (notably property-tax exemptions) with strong preemption and streamlined approvals for qualifying projects. The law requires that at least 40% of units in eligible projects remain affordable for 30 years, and it allows multifamily development in commercial, industrial, or mixed-use zones without rezoning, subject to administrative review.

Read more
1314
2025 Principal Leadership Awards Roundtable Summary

2025 Principal Leadership Awards Roundtable Summary

Principals are second only to teachers in their impact on student learning—and in Florida’s highest-need schools, effective leadership is the catalyst for outsize gains. Florida TaxWatch convened a roundtable on May 14, 2025 with the latest Principal Leadership Awards (PLA) winners to surface the strategies behind sustained improvement. Drawing on data-driven selection (FL-VAM) and firsthand practice, this summary distills what works and why it matters for schools serving predominantly at-risk students.

Read more
151617
18192021222324
25262728293031
1234567

Archive